"...gift for Erika," she whispers.
...Oh. Hm.
Hmm.
You understand the significance, after the surprise dissipates. Witches crave 'material' to 'harvest' don't they? You've been drawing lines with Beatrice, telling her she's not to harm anyone. Perhaps you would both discuss a death by natural causes. But, Erika, on the other hand... she may be more eager.
Having a body ready for her, a live body, even if she's old, would make a nice 'gift' for when Erika arrives. It'd also ensure Oana would die a very painful death.
The only problem is no one would ever know. It'd look like you had lost your nerve at executing someone guilty of attempted regicide. And, would it look like an assassination while she's in a cell? A disappearance? A natural death? Would it look suspicious when Erika had just arrived? --Erika could likely answer those questions herself. She may even be willing to wait the years it'll take for Oana to die naturally. Witches are immortal, after all.
At any rate, you understand Tharja's motivation now. You nod. It takes you a moment to compose yourself, but after doing so, you lead Tharja back to her seat. Gently, only taking yours after she's settled in.
...
You are not ready to make the decision, you realize. Not after that.
But you can't look indecisive.
You tell everyone that with such diverse suggestions, you'll be going around the table, allowing everyone to comment on everyone else's suggestions. If there's further insight to be had, you welcome it.
...That should buy you some time.
You'll start with Robin's suggestion: showing off Ruhemania's military might, then an execution by axe if required, or desired. Thoughts?
"..."
Cordelia doesn't speak, you predict she's not going to have much to add to anything. None of this involves your stables or kennels.
Camilla touches Ricardo's sleeve to get his attention, and he nods to her.
"Expending iron bolts seems a bit of extravagance. We don't have a lot of room to grant the military replacements for their equipment."
Robin simply waves. "The iron can be salvaged. New arrows will cost nothing. This is for the display of military might and the weapons we have to show we are a superior force."
Corrin speaks next: "Death by firing a crossbow could potentially leave a lasting impression, for exactly that reason. The General's suggestion fits in line with my opinion. The only question is," he pauses, looking at her. "Will the arrows hit their mark? Even one hit will make Ruhemania look very foolish."
"Every bolt will hit its target," Robin retorts. "I will stake my reputation on it."
Father Tomas doesn't speak. You're not sure if he will at all, though he's not inattentive.
It's Mania's turn.
"...This style of execution is done more for vanity than justice. The spirits in the weapons will be done a disservice."
Robin's lips twist in acknowledgement. You think Mania made a criticism that Robin actually considered.
Tharja makes no comment, except to say she's committed to her own suggestion.
All right. That's enough for Robin.
...The method suggested by your Master of Coin, Ricardo? The 'old Ruhemania' way. The stake.
... It seems no one wants to speak up. You finally gesture to Robin and say you'd like her to offer something.
She frowns, but then thinks it over. "It may put a stress on the guards to take care of Oana knowing she's about to suffer the stake. Moving her to a cage. Force-feeding her syrup. ...You know."
Robin's talk seems to have loosened everyone's lips: Camilla speaks next. "One can't deny it's cost effective," she murmurs, a very nervous smile turning her lips for a moment.
Corrin's turn next. He shows unease that is rare for him in how he squirms in his seat. "I can't deny that is a style of execution that will strike fear everywhere, Your Majesty. It will definitely be known, and talked about. However... it might be going a little too overboard. The respect of a harsh punishment may bring fear for closer relations with other countries."
Father Tomas raises a hand to speak, and you allow it. "It's needlessly cruel. Even if it's traditional. That's all."
Then, Mania. "The return of this 'tradition' will attract the negative attention of the spirits, who only have recently come to offer their blessings to this castle. But... as I said, the woman does deserve the stake."
Tharja remains firm. Father Tomas didn't have a suggestion, so that brings you to Mania's proposition. Giving Oana her own sort of 'trial' among the peasants, and then beheading her in a show of just punishment, with the people around to condemn her as well. ...Thoughts?
Robin tilts her head, ever so slightly, side to side. "It is a fair punishment. Lacking in spectacle, and more than Oana deserves, but I can see that it will be appreciated by the commoners, Your Majesty." Mania shares a nod with Robin.
Camilla speaks next: "I just want to caution that a day peasants spend celebrating is a day less they can be working the fields, especially at harvest time."
...Oh no. You don't look back at Mania, but you can't imagine the expression on her face must be livid. That Camilla would talk about the peasants not being 'worked hard enough.'
Corrin, you say, prompting him. The likely impact of that punishment?
Corrin steeples his hands, then speaks. "It is a good idea, Your Majesty. It is a pleasant theory. However, if you give Oana the opportunity to speak to you, or say anything, where people can hear it, you are giving her a tiny sliver of power. She may take it, somehow. Blurt out some accusations against you. Some secret about the castle. Something like that. I think her display at the gathering and how she went from pleading to her life to insulting your authority is proof of that."
...Yes, it's true. Oana threw every dagger she could think of at you, in the end, when she was taken captive. You can't help but shut your eyes in revulsion. In sympathy. For Dimitrie. That he suffered with her his entire life. How could such a woman be a mother...?
At any rate, Corrin has made a good point. You press on to ask of the others. Any suggestions, you ask?
This time Cordelia does speak up. "I believe I can arrange for dogs to be present which could bark on command and drown her out her words, Your Majesty."
Well, that's something. You'll keep it in mind. Father Tomas, you prompt?
"This seems more a celebration than as a true show of a just punishment. But, it's still within your right, of course."
Tharja remains firm and lets her opportunity to speak pass.
Mania adds her retort to Corrin's caution about Oana being heard. "There's no need to worry. And no need for dogs. The people themselves will not listen to her. What I've suggested is the most just way to end the evil woman's life."
Corrin asks for the opportunity for one last word: "Similarly, it may appease the peasants, but whether it truly inspires fear and respect from our neighbors in matters of diplomacy, that's unlikely."
...
You're at the part no one wants to get to: Tharja's suggestion of just leaving Oana in her cell in the dungeon.
You emphasize to everyone that they should remember this is your wife, Her Royal Highness, and she carries your heirs. Do not upset her with harsh speak.
Tharja looks at you and you share a smile. Though, you think it may be less from your chivalry and more that you're playing along with the idea that she will have twins. Well, why not? She just might.
Robin composes herself, then begins: "The guards really don't like taking care of her. She screams. She at times refuses to eat. She'll pretend she's sick for sympathy, or huddle in a corner and not move to make the guards believe she's dead. Even Margaret is a better prisoner. Having to deal with that for however many years it takes for the woman to actually die will stress the guards."
You nod. They don't know Erika would end her life, but from their point of view, it makes complete sense.
Camilla speaks next: "It is only one person, and it's not as if gruel is particularly expensive, but it would be another factor not to consider in the budget were she to be executed."
It's not much of a criticism, but it's something. Perhaps Camilla only spoke just for the sake of it. You lead the talk to Corrin next, though you're very sure of what he has to say.
"I hate to be so blunt, Your Majesty, but it is likely the very worst of all suggestions proposed today. It's effectively announcing there is no real punishment for regicide. It may bring assassins or worse."
That seems a little extreme. What if you made Margaret's execution particularly bad, to compensate?
Corrin has no answer to that. He simply shakes his head.
Father Tomas, you ask?
"..."
He seems finally animated. He takes a deep breath and looks up at you all. You can see his eyes are shining.
"I think, were the King to spare the woman who orchestrated his murder to life in the dungeon..." His eyes blink rapidly, he has a bright smile. "It would surely be the greatest act of mercy. Akin to when the Savior walked the Earth."
"The potential for repentance exists in everyone. I'd ask to be allowed to visit her personally and offer her the guidance necessary to change her ways. Not with the offer of escaping your prison, Your Majesty, but of freeing her soul from Damnation."
--Oh, wow. The reference to the Savior is... startling. You have a feeling this would impress Father Tomas more than anything you've done yet. That it would be proof of the miracle of Tharja's faith. He may even advocate you for Sainthood if you keep this up.
On a more practical matter, if Father Tomas is attending to Oana, that means Father Tomas is not around the actual castle so much. It might be easier to interact with the nuns, then. Easier to get to know them... endear yourself to them... show them the joy of motherhood and plan your trysts...
That alone makes the idea attractive. In addition to a nice 'gift for Erika'.
...Ah, Mania needs her turn. You expect she won't be happy, but... you nod that she will be the last to speak, about this issue and everything discussed.
"..."
"Sir, I would ask to approach your wife."
You're startled at the request. You exchange a glance with Tharja. Tharja makes a little shrug in response. You turn back and say you approve.
Mania creeps from her seat, around the table, until she's facing down Tharja. She... looks at her. She's just looking at her. What does she see, you wonder?
Mania tilts her head as Tharja seems a bit unnerved by the invasion of her personal space.
"Sir, I would ask that your wife meet my eyes."
... You don't want to tell her 'no'. You gently stroke Tharja's thigh and beg her to play along.
Tharja dips her head, before nodding. She turns back toward Mania and they meet face-to-face. Mania gives her a very intense stare.
"...Her motives are not for herself. Her motives are selfless. That is what the spirits surrounding Sir's wife tell this hag." Mania finally breaks eye contact.
"I hear a whisper that if this decision passes Sir's approval, the dynamic of this council will change. --That's all." She then goes to sit down.
...Well, she's not wrong. This is basically overruling everyone's advice. Except Father Tomas, who is basically a soft-hearted fool.
At any rate, you'll have to wonder what Mania was doing later. You vaguely remember the first time you met with Mania, in her cart. How she looked at you and asked if you were a good King or a bad King. This may have been a repeat of that. Her own appraisal.
Though Tharja's request being made in selflessness is correct.
And... you can't put this off any longer. You need to decide.
This is perhaps the most complicated decision you've had to make as King. It will be done within the castle walls, and yet will surely stretch into eternity as the first time you show your capacity for punishing one who wronged you. Cruel, resolute, firm, champion of the people, pious...?
No putting it off. You go over the possibilities once more...
Choice time:
1. Robin's proposal. Have Oana executed as an excuse to show off the military.
>(Council's expectations of being heard increases. Robin's influence increases. Robin's faction's satisfaction goes up. Ricardo's faction's satisfaction goes down. Mania's faction's satisfaction goes down. Tharja's satisfaction goes down.)
2. Ricardo's proposal. Sharpen a stake. Return to the 'old tradition' of punishment... hopefully just this once.
>(Council's expectations of being heard increases. Ricardo's influence increases. Every faction's satisfaction goes down. (Including Ricardo's.))
3. Corrin's proposal. Just something for show, it doesn't matter what. Cruel, but not that cruel. Makes no long lasting statement.
>(Council's expectations of being heard increases. Corrin's influence increases. Robin's satisfaction goes down. Mania's satisfaction goes down. Tharja's satisfaction goes down.)
4. Mania's proposal. Have Oana brought out in the open, among the commoners, and read her sentence like a trial. Allow her to speak, before having her decapitated.
>(Council's expectations of being heard increases. Mania's influence increases. Corrin's satisfaction decreases. Tharja's satisfaction decreases.)
5. Mania's proposal, but bring in braying dogs trained to drown Oana's words out on command. She doesn't deserve to speak, on sheer principle.
> (Council's expectations of being heard increases. Mania and Cordelia's influence increases. Mania's satisfaction decreases. Cordelia's satisfaction increases. Corrin's satisfaction decreases. Tharja's satisfaction decreases.)
6. Tharja's proposal. Leave Oana to rot in the dungeon. Almost everyone will hate it, but she's to be kept as a gift for Erika, and you're sure your witches will be happy with it.
>(Council's expectations of being heard decreases. Tharja will become a new faction and permanently join the Council. Outwardly, she will be judged by Monarch Authority shared with Edward, but privately she will represent the witches in the Castle and their needs. Everyone's satisfaction decreases. Except for Father Tomas' faction, which will increase greatly. Tharja's new faction's satisfaction will also increase greatly.)
7. Something else. (Write-in. How it affects the Balance of Power will be noted.)
Here we see very early there is already a chance for a big change to the Balance of Power. By voting for Tharja's proposal, she will cease to be a guest and instead join the table. She will become a member of the council with the others, but the actual faction she represents will be a secret. Tharja will represent the interests of the witches (Beatrice, Erika, and Herself) presented in mundane form. To the outward appearance, it will appear Edward is sharing his Monarch Authority with Tharja. It's more likely (but not guaranteed) that selecting Tharja's proposals will be seen as Edward overruling the Council in their advice, with those risks and benefits. Tharja's role as Edward's love and wife will mean she won't plot against him. Similar to Mania, Tharja is irreplaceable. Neither Beatrice nor Erika will join the council, so Tharja joining or sitting as a guest will be the only way the 'witch faction' will be heard. However, since Tharja is also representing Beatrice and Erika's issues, she will leave or stop making guest appearances if the witches' needs are ignored. Edward is not just interacting with Tharja, but vicariously Erika and Beatrice.
Questions will be answered if anyone has any. Write-ins are also acceptable if they do not contradict the medieval(ish) setting or are otherwise impossible to use.